Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Search in posts
Search in pages

Shock Collar Alternatives for Dogs

Shock Collar Alternatives For Dogs
This post may contain affiliate links and we will receive a small commission if you make a purchase after clicking on our link. Read the Disclosure Policy.
(Image via Unsplash)

Training is an essential part of being a responsible dog owner, but it’s not always easy. Every dog is different, and every owner has a different philosophy. So when it comes to training, some owners don’t mind using a shock collar, but others want to stay away from that sort of thing—they go looking for shock collar alternatives for their dogs. 

If it’s your first time shopping for dog training options, you may not know where to start. This article is a guide to shock collar alternatives, reviewing their prices, features, and customer feedback. Finding the perfect option for your pup just got easier!

1. Halo 2+ Collar

Usually $999, right now you can buy this collar for $699 using the code HALOFREEDOM. It may seem costly, but this collar really does have it all. There are also payment plans available. 


  • Built-in advanced GPS/GNSS to create accurate wireless dog fences
  • Up to 20 unique wireless dog fences
  • Dog training program designed by Cesar Millan
  • Customizable feedback using sound, vibration, and static
  • Dog activity tracker and daily activity charts
  • Waterproof and improved durability
  • 20+ hour battery life
  • One-size-fits-most, with flexible comfort fit—replaceable strap in small, medium, and large

With 404 reviews, this collar earns a 4.7-star rating out of 5. Many reviews mention the peace of mind they have using this collar. Another common mention is how easy the system is to use. Labeled “The Holy Grail of dog collars”, this shock collar alternative is definitely worth looking into. 

2. Citronella Training Collar

 At $79.99, this collar is less expensive and can offer quality results. It comes with a remote because it doesn’t work automatically—owners will have to manually activate the feedback.


  • 3 Feedback modes:
    • Citronella spray
    • Vibration
    • Beep
  • 3 Spray mode levels:
    • High
    • Low
    • No spray
  • Works within a 1000-foot range
  • Adjustable collar for breeds over 8 pounds
  • Collar refills can last up to 30-35 sprays, and there are 300-400 sprays per can
  • 11-day collar battery life and 27-day remote battery life
  • Slightly rainproof

This collar has 739 ratings on Amazon and has a 4 out of 5 stars rating. Many reviews mention not even having to use the spray mode yet; their dogs are responding well to the beep and/or vibration. For owners who have used other citronella collars, they say this is the best one they’ve ever used. 

3. ACME 212 Training Whistle

At only $10.61, this is one of the cheapest options you’ll see on the list. However, this type of equipment requires a lot more effort on the owner’s part for training. 


  • Highly visible for your dog
  • Small and high-pitched (Not a silent whistle)
  • Holds tone over distance
  • Extremely simple

This whistle has 492 reviews on Amazon and holds a 4 out of 5 stars rating. Many reviewers discussed how quickly their dog became accustomed to the whistle, learning commands as quickly as a ten-minute session. Something that many people recommended was buying a lanyard to go along with the whistle. 

4. Richell 3-in-1 Convertible Elite Pet Gate

For $305.14, this “pet gate” is much more than simply a gate. With payment plans available, this is one of the more expensive alternatives, but still affordable.


  • Converts to a freestanding gate, a room divider, and a pet pen
  • Optional panel and wire top sold separately
  • Recommended for small to large dogs (8-44 pounds)
  • Easy to store
  • Lockable gate
  • Caps to lock panels in place at 90- and 180-degree angles
  • Available in a 4-panel or a 6-panel option

This item has 923 ratings on Amazon and boasts a 4.7-star rating out of 5. Many reviews mention phrases such as “easy to assemble”, “well made”, “looks nice”, “highly recommend”, and “worth the money”. So whether you need a gate, a divider, or a pen, this option is great for training your pooch. 

5. PetSafe Clik-R Clicker

For an incredibly low price of $3.99, this dog clicker is another easy-purchase item that usually requires more hands-on training from you, the owner. While you can use it by itself, it is encouraged to use treats alongside the clicker, so keep that cost in mind as well. 


  • Ergonomic and easy to hold
  • Attached finger band for added comfort
  • Easy to use for all ages
  • Easy to learn from for dogs, cats, and even children
  • Established brand since 1991

With a whopping 17,457 reviews, the clicker is rated 4.2 stars out of 5. Many customers talk about its simplicity and how quickly their pet caught on to the training. It’s worth mentioning many reviews also stated the button was a little hard to push, so if you have arthritis, you may want to consider a different option. 

We hope you found this list of shock collar alternatives for dogs informative and helpful. As we said, every dog and owner is different, so the method of training for you as a dynamic duo is ultimately up to you!

You Might Also Like

Follow us on Instagram @earnspendlive